Vital signing

 "At the very least, Alexander Buttner's arrival should allow Patrice Evra vital time to rest and recover at strategic points throughout 2012/13. The Frenchman's missed just three league games in the last three seasons."

- Nick Coppack,

Post your opinions on our message board at

23/08/2012 13:30, Report by Nick Coppack
1 of 2 Next 

Blog: Buttner's cover story's Nick Coppack thinks Patrice Evra may benefit most from Alexander Buttner's arrival at OT ...

Like most United fans, I suspect, I've not watched much Dutch football over the last few years.

PSV Eindhoven? The odd glimpse in a highlights package. Ajax? Well, we played them in last season's Europa League. But Vitesse Arnhem, former club of United's new signing Alexander Buttner? Not a jot.

Consequently, I've never seen the 23-year-old play, so I can only assume reports claiming Sir Alex has signed a tricky left-back with blistering pace and an eye for goal (he used to be a winger) are correct.

Buttner definitely isn't a superstar. And perhaps that's why some fans have taken to social media and online forums to decry his arrival. But just because he's not already established on the global stage – or even one of the Eredivisie's big guns (see Ajax's Christian Eriksson and Jan Vertonghen or Herenveen’s Bas Dost) – it doesn't mean he can't have a big future at Manchester United.

Nemanja Vidic was hardly a household name when he arrived in January 2006. Neither was Patrice Evra. And both of them have turned out to be pretty decent defensive signings.

Evra, of course, will find himself in direct competition with Buttner for the left-back spot, a scenario that should get the best out of the Frenchman. After all, there's no greater motivator for a footballer than the threat of losing your place in the starting XI.

Over time, Buttner may well edge past Evra (now 31) in the pecking order and make the left-back spot his own. But just as beneficial is the cover he offers in the short-term. And it is an area where the Reds need cover.

Somehow, like the solitary house that miraculously remains standing in a hurricane that wipes out all else around it, Patrice Evra has been almost ever-present in a United defence that's been consistently ravaged by injury. Indeed, Evra's missed just three league games in the last three seasons and

1 of 2 Next 


Premier League