Ben Foster
A touch unlucky with the goal as Tello's shot took a deflection, but he may feel he should have got a hand to the ball. Otherwise had little to do.

Gary Neville
Got forward well down the right flank, particularly in the first half. His final ball wasn't always on the money but overall he was solid.

Wes Brown
Didn't put a foot wrong at the back and was agonisingly close to rescuing a point with an injury-time header.

Nemanja Vidic
Like Brown, Vida was solid in defence and won almost all his headers and tackles. The goal aside, Besiktas' forwards barely threatened.

Rafael
Played out of position on the right but it didn't seem to bother the young Brazilian. He was unlucky to deflect Tello's shot into the net.

Gabriel Obertan
Probably the Reds' liveliest player. Showed plenty of promise. Ever willing to attack with pace and a blur of stepovers.

Darron Gibson
Began the game brightly, but will be disappointed not to have taken the game by the scruff of the neck on a rare start