The story of the FA Community Shield

Saturday 10 August 2024 17:21

Manchester United performed well but narrowly lost the FA Community Shield on penalties, following a 1-1 draw in normal time.

The Reds controlled the game and created the better opportunities, leading to substitute Alejandro Garnacho breaking the deadlock after 82 minutes with an excellent finish. 

Bernardo Silva equalised with a back-post header in the final moments of normal time - their only shot on target - and spot-kicks were required, leading to the Blues snatching the trophy with a 7-6 win. 

While disappointed not to lift the shield, Erik ten Hag’s Reds can take lots of positives from the occasion and the attention now turns to next Friday’s Premier League opener against Fulham.

Read on for more details from the game...

90 in 20: Manchester City v United Video

90 in 20: Manchester City v United

90 IN 20 | Extended highlights from our Community Shield clash with Manchester City are available here...

FIRST HALF

Ten Hag named a strong line-up at Wembley, with returning internationals Diogo Dalot, Lisandro Martinez and Bruno Fernandes making their first appearances of the summer, but new signing Joshua Zirkzee remained an unused substitute as the Dutchman continues to build his fitness. 

Pep Guardiola picked a youthful side, as he hinted at in his pre-match press conference, albeit with star striker Erling Haaland leading the line following a fruitful pre-season campaign. 

The Blues controlled the ball throughout the opening stages and mostly in United’s half, leading to their first meaningful opportunity in the 22nd minute when tricky winger Oscar Bobb cut inside from the right to lash a left-footed high and wide of Andre Onana’s goal. Moments later, James McAtee saw a shot bounce off the post after pouncing on a loose ball from Martinez. 

Those chances sparked United into life and the Reds immediately moved up the pitch, leading to our first chance: Amad drove up the right wing, jinked between two markers and hit a left-footed shot just wide of the far post, highlighting his sharpness following a positive Tour 2024. 

The Ivory Coast international was then involved in a lovely team move, exchanging passes with Casemiro to run through on goal, before unselfishly squaring a ball back inside. Unfortunately, Amad’s pass did not find Mason Mount and our no.16 perhaps should have shot instead. 

United finished the half in the ascendancy and playing some lovely football with intricate passing moves. The most impressive led to Marcus Rashford shooting wide on 38 minutes. 

SECOND HALF

Joy quickly became frustration in the 54th minute as the linesman’s delayed flag correctly disallowed a Fernandes ‘goal’ for offside. The Portuguese talisman had unleashed a delicious strike into the top corner from 25 yards. 

Ten Hag made four changes just before the hour mark, handing Toby Collyer his competitive debut after a number of impressive pre-season performances. In the process, the 20-year-old midfielder became the 251st debutant from our legendary Academy. Facundo Pellistri also returned to United action, at right-back, following his loan spell at Granada last season. 

The game began to open up in the latter stages as tired legs appeared on both sides, leading to more spaces and opportunities to score. Bruno was again in the thick of it, latching onto a wonderful pass from the excellent Casemiro to see a first-time shot saved by Ederson.

Rashford hit the post with a left-footed shot and, moments later, the no.10’s downward header from a corner led to Scott McTominay stretching in vein to convert from close range.  

United’s pressure eventually paid off and it was substitute Garnacho who broke the deadlock, cutting inside from the right wing, drifting past two defenders and drilling a left-footed shot into the bottom corner, sparking jubilant scenes.

Parity was unfortunately restored in the 89th minute as City replacement Bernardo headed in at the back post, prompting a penalty shootout.

Full 90: Manchester City v United Video

Full 90: Manchester City v United

FULL 90 | Watch every second from Manchester City v United in the 2024 FA Community Shield...

PENALTY SHOOTOUT

Here's what happened in the spot kicks...

Bruno Fernandes: Scored
Bernardo Silva: Missed

Diogo Dalot: Scored
Kevin De Bruyne: Scored

Alejandro Garnacho: Scored
Erling Haaland: Scored

Jadon Sancho: Missed
Savinho: Scored

Casemiro:Scored
Ederson: Scored

Scott McTominay: Scored
Nunes: Scored

Lisandro Martinez: Scored
Ruben Dias: Scored

Jonny Evans: Missed
Manuel Akanji: Scored

We're disappointed not to lift the trophy, but it was an encouraging display at Wembley. Who is your Man of the Match?poll

We're disappointed not to lift the trophy, but it was an encouraging display at Wembley. Who is your Man of the Match?

LINE-UPS
 
United: 
Onana, Dalot, Maguire (Pellistri 58’), Evans, Martinez, Casemiro, Mainoo (McTominay 58’), Amad (Garnacho 58’), Mount (Collyer 58’), Rashford (Sancho 84’), Fernandes.
Subs not used: 
Bayindir, Eriksen, Antony, Zirkzee.

Man City: 
Ederson; Lewis, Akanji, Dias (c), Gvardiol (Ake 90'); Kovacic, O’Reilly (Nunes 65'), McAtee (Bernardo 80’); Bobb (De Bruyne 90'), Haaland, Doku (Savinho 65').
Subs not used: 
Ortega Moreno, Carson, Phillips, Kabore.
Bookings: 
Nunes, Bernardo

Attendance: 
TBC

MATCH STATS

Possession:
Man City 56% United 44%
Shots:
Man City 9 United 8
Shots on target:
Man City 1 United 2
Corners:
Man City 6 United 2

Recommended: