Former Brighton & Hove Albion midfielder who joined the club in 2022.

Toby was part of Travis Binnion's young squad which travelled to San Diego for the Wrexham friendly in July 2023, with the young midfielder starting the game at the Snapdragon Stadium. After making further progress with the Under-21s, Collyer was included on the first-team bench on several occasions towards the back end of 2023/24, before impressing on Tour 2024 in the States. He made his senior debut as a substitute on 10 August 2024, as United lost to Manchester City in the Community Shield on penalties. Toby joined West Bromwich Albion on loan for the 2025/26 season, on 15 August 2025. He returned to United in January, before moving to Hull City at the end of the window.